Mmastodon WorldReligion first seen 6 h ago, last 55 min ago, peak #8

Former member says Amish preacher phoned to condemn him to hell

Original: Amish preacher calls me just to tell me that I am going to hell. https://youtu.be/SGXHy8QIHsg?si=Fnm3fFWnGd6zDzMH Many p

A person describing themselves as a former member of the Amish community says an Amish preacher telephoned them simply to tell them they are going to hell. They argue the Amish are widely romanticised as gentle, old-fashioned people of faith, but that former members describe a far harsher reality, including shunning and condemnation of those who leave.

Why now: The claim challenges the popularly favourable image of the Amish, prompting discussion about treatment of people who leave the community.

Amishformer Amish community members

Open on mastodon →

Evidence

• Amish preacher calls me just to tell me that I am going to hell. https://youtu.be/SGXHy8QIHsg?si=Fnm3fFWnGd6zDzMH Many people think the Amish are 'good people' with a anitiquated 'faith'. Some former Amish will tell you it is quite different than many perceive. The Amish are… · 8@star.octade.net · 2

API: https://socialmediatrends-api.osmike.com/v1/trends/411859